jobworksaz Quick Search
more options
HelpHomeJob SearchOur EmployersJob Seeker TipsOn TvPlace Jobs

New Job Notify
My Job List

Job Seeker Tips
Evaluate Career-Marketing Firm: Real Thing or Racket
By Joyce Lain Kennedy

Dear Joyce: My son-in-law is 57 and lost his job. A manager, he has contacted a company that says if he pays them $4,000 plus, they will market him through special connections bypassing the personnel departments in corporations. What do you think? -- V.L.

Dear V.L.: Here we go again: When the economy declines, scams become a growth industry.

School Posing as Employer
In its Jan. 8 edition, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported a reprise of the training school dodge. The Missouri attorney general has filed a lawsuit alleging deceptive trade practices by two men in St. Louis who set up a computer-services company supposedly to provide technical support to other companies.

The company advertised jobs paying $45,000 a year. The catch was that commission salespeople posing as human resource employees told job applicants they couldn't be hired until they paid up to $3,150 for training.

Career-Marketing
Another variety of schemes -- the so called "executive marketing firms" or "career-marketing firms" -- run alluring ads promising amazing but phony benefits. Their false promises are built around "insider" claims and selectivity. A few examples:

"We will market you through our special channels and get you in front of hiring managers."

"We will give you access to unpublished job openings in the hidden job market."

"We will give you a list of 70 exclusive names you can call to get top jobs."

"We will see to it that you get the right job and will continue at your side until that happens."

Bad Pennies
Unscrupulous career-marketing firms have existed for decades, preying on people who are unemployed or in going-nowhere jobs.

The most recent example was described last week in the San Diego Union Tribune as a firm that has dropped from sight, leaving employees in limbo and customers enraged.

The firm collected $4,000 and $5,000 fees for advice on how to get jobs paying from $60,000 to $600,000.

Their written contract stated, "No verbal or written promises or guarantee of any job or employment is made or implied." But that's not the way sales reps talked, according to numerous ex-customers.

"I was promised upper echelon jobs, but they put me in a few classes," said a dissatisfied customer, who noted he could have obtained the same thing from a book. Another angry customer said he paid thousands for a résumé that he found to be uselessly out of sync with the industries they were supposed to target.

More Skinny
A detailed account of how con artists rip off bright, experienced managers - "The Executive Marketing Racket: How I dropped ten grand down a hole" -- is found on the Ask the Headhunter Web site.

Tips
In the meantime, here are several pointers on how to tell the bad guys from the good guys.

  • Bypass firms that make absurd statements about having legions of reliable alumni who perpetuate an old school network for the firm's customers. Think about it for two seconds and you realize that even the most appreciative alums would get sick and tired of accommodating waves of new job seekers.
  • Beware the career-marketer who says the firm is picky about who it takes on as customers. They really want to know if your credit card is maxed out. If there's any nonsense about referring your application to a committee, they're stalling to find out if you can pay and hope the delay will whet your appetite to "qualify."
  • Ask to meet your counselor, not the sales representative who may exaggerate potential benefits.
  • Shop career service providers, get referrals from friends, check references and query the local better business bureau.

    Pay as You Go
    Pay for career guidance by the hour or short project and sign no contracts. That way you can walk away if dissatisfied.

    Yes, I've heard the vendors' argument that an up-front fee keeps you committed to the program. That contention reminds me of my good intentions last January when I paid a year in advance to join a fitness center. My commitment to exercise was no better than when my two-left-feet father signed up for Arthur Murray's lifetime dancing lessons.

    Send career questions for possible use in this column to Joyce Lain Kennedy at Box 368, Cardiff, CA 92007, or e-mail her at jlk@sunfeatures.com. Sorry, the volume of mail makes personal replies impossible.

    ©2001 Tribune Media Services, Inc.

    Back


  • Job Categories
    Administrative
    Airlines
    Arts/Media
    Automotive
    Computer/IT/IS
    Construction/Trades
    Customer Service
    Education/Training
    Engineering/Architecture
    Finance/Banking/Accounting
    Government
    Healthcare
    Hospitality/Resorts
    Human Resources
    Insurance
    Legal/Law Enforcement
    Management/Professional
    Manufacturing/Production
    Nursing
    Real Estate
    Restaurants
    Retail
    Sales/Marketing
    Other

    Help | Home | Job Search | Our Employers | Job Seeker Tips | As Seen On Tv | Place Jobs

    Terms and Conditions
    © Copyright 1996-2001 Belo Interactive Inc., All Rights Reserved.
    An azfamily.com Production